Sweet & Spicy Barbecue Sauce (Recipe)

written by

posted on

April 28, 2021

If you enjoy barbecue sauce but don’t like the typical preservative-filled ingredient list on bottled sauce, you’re going to love the simple ingredients and amazing flavor in this homemade version.

It has a touch of sweetness, without being overly cloying. Plus, it offers a bit of heat but not so much that the spiciness overpowers the delicious flavor of the meat.

Most homemade barbecue sauce recipes start with ketchup, but I prefer crushed tomatoes or tomato sauce for several reasons. While this recipe works fine with ketchup, if your goal is to cut out the preservatives typically found in commercial sauces, make sure to check the ingredients on the ketchup.

Also, tomato sauce and crushed tomatoes are typically more economical – and saving money is another great reason to make your own condiments!

Tomato sauce makes a smoother version. Crushed tomatoes add some nice texture. You can always pulse it with a stick blender if you find it's too much texture for your liking.

If you’re avoiding refined sugar, you can replace the brown sugar with additional honey and molasses to taste. If you prefer more heat, you can add the optional cayenne.

This recipe is so easy, economical, and delicious that we like to make a double batch and keep it on hand in a quart mason jar in the fridge. It makes the perfect finishing touch for ribs, meatballs, burgers or meatloaf!

Click here for a printable PDF download of this recipe.

Sweet & Spicy Barbecue Sauce

Makes about 2 cups

Ingredients

1 ¼ C tomato sauce or crushed tomatoes

½ C brown sugar

¼ C molasses

2 T honey

5 T apple cider vinegar

1 T worcestershire sauce

2 ½ tsp ground mustard

2 tsp garlic powder

2 tsp smoked paprika

1 ½ tsp salt

½ tsp black pepper

Optional: 1/8 tsp cayenne for additional heat

Directions

Combine all ingredients in a small saucepan. Bring to a simmer over medium heat, stirring often. Allow to simmer for a few minutes. Optional, carefully give the sauce a few pulses with a stick blender. Use immediately or store in the fridge in a glass jar.

This sauce is the perfect finish for our Mouthwatering Spare Ribs recipe or slathered on The BEST Meatballs.

Bust out the napkins!

Click here to order Pork Spare Ribs.

Click here to order Ground Beef.

🎥 Meet the chickens behind your favorite eggs. [video]

I’m taking you behind the scenes today with a video🎥 to help answer the question: “Why are your eggs so good?” That’s a question we get all the time, and I’m not sure how to answer it. Not because I don’t know the answer, but because I don’t know where to begin. Because the actual boots-on-the-ground logistics of what we do is super complex. And every piece of the puzzle contributes to the health of the hens, and thereby the flavor and nutrition of the eggs. 🐓 moving hundreds of chickens outdoors on fresh pasture 🦅 while keeping them from getting eaten by everything else 🌾mixing our own feed so it’s always super fresh 🐤working with a nutritionist so each hen gets exactly what she needs at each stage of her life 🥚keeping eggs in stock year-round ⛈️ proper housing in the winter to protect the soil and the hens 📜 the list goes on It’s no surprise when someone asks me a question like that, I immediately start composing in my head a 5-paragraph essay 📝 - complete with introductory sentences, supporting evidence, and a compelling conclusion. All the time knowing it’s going to come out how Charlie Brown heard his teacher – “wah wah wah”. 😄 Luckily, I mentioned my problem to Farmer Martin and he boiled it down to TWO WORDS. Fresh. Feed. Ha! Why couldn’t I think of that? 🤷‍♀️ At this moment of the year, Fresh Feed means the most gorgeous grass on God’s green earth. 🎥 So, if a picture’s worth a thousand words, I decided to spare you the 5-paragraph essay and bring you a 48 second video instead. Farmhand Grace was happy to hop on the tractor with her farmer-daddy to make the trek out to the pasture and help show you around. I’m not making promises about the video quality. 🎬 I didn’t plan out what I should say (I would have managed to turn it into an unendurable 5-paragraph essay). And fair warning if you get motion sickness, there’s a moment at the beginning where I spun the camera a little fast because I had a premonition of approaching danger… I’m not going to spoil it by telling you what it was - suffice it to say my instincts were correct. And while I apologize for the poor filming and any queasy stomachs, it’s pretty much real farm life in action. 👩‍🌾🥰 You’ll meet the hens, some of the guardians who keep them safe, and catch a glimpse of your farmers, too.Click on the image at the top of this post to watch the video. And don’t forget to grab some eggs for this week. With its bounty, Spring’s a great time to add extra eggs to your weekly protein routine. I’ve got several family-favorite recipes linked on the egg page to bring you inspiration for breakfast or dinner, like Cheesy Egg Bites, Dutch Babies and Potato Salad. Click here to get the best eggs.